I thought Memphis had a terrible game if I'm honest, so I don't share the same opinion with you on that and I was happy to see him subbed.I thought Memphis was still one of our better players. No idea why Schweinsteiger was subbed either, another questionable substitution for me. I think the subs helped the opposition more than they helped us actually.
The point about the team going to shit is why I thought Pereira sub was a strange one. I don't think he's going to make a difference to that team at that time. I'm not blaming Pereira for anything, I'm blaming the manager!
15
Season Average Rating
- Appearances
- 11
- Goals
- 1
- Assists
- 0
- Yellow cards
- 0
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik @Rood and Imran @Annihilate Now! start with the good news by celebrating Manchester United Women's emphatic FA Cup win over Spurs at Wembley and the future of manager Marc Skinner.
Then it's the bad news and the ever worsening form of our Men with losses to Arsenal and Palace.
Finally the main debate - ETH Out now or keep him until the end of the season - if not longer. Are you Team Nik or Team Imran?
- Status
Why with Memphis is always polemic?
Memphis was terrible IMO.I thought Memphis was still one of our better players. No idea why Schweinsteiger was subbed either, another questionable substitution for me. I think the subs helped the opposition more than they helped us actually.
The point about the team going to shit is why I thought Pereira sub was a strange one. I don't think he's going to make a difference to that team at that time. I'm not blaming Pereira for anything, I'm blaming the manager!
Exactly.
Admittedly, I have seen little of Perreira but he is defentivelly not a #8. #10 or a inside forward as you said, that much is obvious.
he was, he has been for a while.
Coming on at a difficult time when the team was on the defensive. Unfair to judge him on this performance.
I think it's unfair to to criticize him for this performance. He did well.
Kudos to lvg.... Had some balls to bring on the kid at that particular time. Much needed experience that for andreas
I thought it was borderline stupidity in an important game like that to bring him on. Wasn't the time to give him much needed experience, we needed someone who already had the experience!
Who else would have came on for a very tired Memphis. I don’t think it was stupid. I respect that he gives these kids a chance. Especially in this kind of manner. Gives them such a boost of confidence I think
LVG shows he rates him by putting him in a difficult period. Wolfsburg were going to hunt for a goal which meant he had to be ready on the defensive end but, also brought on to exploit the space they would likely leave. I think he was found wanting a little on both sides and no shame in that, there will be other games that's for sure and needs to be ready for the next one.
Damn fine question, wish I knew where this came from. I was in the Memphis thread earlier today and you would think he went on a rampage and killed several fans family members. I came over here expecting the same lashing out on Pereira only to find that it was everyone else's fault he didn't play well.
I think he did alright given the situation he was put in and am thrilled LVG made the call to put him on. I thought Wolfsburg targeted him (or at least that side) immediately, had a little success but he fought through it and eventually they gave up and tried AY to see what they could do there. I am sure the kid was shitting his pants and was more worried about making a mistake that cost the team a win than really focusing on trying to do something when on the ball. Just like Memphis, the more he is put in these situations the more it will help him grow as a player.
Cpuld it be that when we first signed him so many in the transfer thread were acting like we had signed the next Messi?. From that we end up with some sort of backlash?.
Well, I guess if the expectations were that he would come in and be our Messi then I can see where people come up with seeing him as, as one poster put it, a "clumsy brain dead cnut". Not sure that I feel that is fair to Memphis though, or any young player for that matter.
I think both Memphis and Pereira are going to be integral parts of this team for a long time but it's going to take some time/experiences to get there. And I hate to keep saying this because I feel like I might be alone with the thought, but the entire team is still getting their chops down, learning what the manager expects of them, learning what each other likes to do/not do and are showing glimpses of putting things together. But to expect to throw a bunch of guys on the pitch and have them perform flawlessly is unrealistic and to point at any one player and say they are the one that are holding things back is a bit rash imo.
I'm bemused at this too. Some on here expecting instant success from all our players, and to be fair those who are on £250k/week and have years of experience playing at a top level I agree with, but knocking the kids? Does anybody remember how bad Ronaldo was in the first few months with us, and allot of people were calling for him to be dropped too, but SAF stuck with him.
He'd have been a far more inspiring introduction than Fellaini or Valencia, I can promise you that.
Yep. A pity he wasn't on the bench. Could have been a straight swap for Depay.
Behind Lingard in the pecking order now?
Van Gaal has just said Lingard is competition for Mata on the right. Andreas is more of a #10 (well, a #8, really) who when played has featured on the left.
... i don't get it. i'm confused. not even on the bench?
Hopefully has another solid impact on the match.
Delighted he's got his chance, seems like he's playing in Herrera's #8 role.
Man Utd 0:0 Middlesbrough
Our best player in the first half his passing in particular has been very impressive.
Done pretty well today so far.
He's class, should be seeing more of him in League fixtures.
Which was his best role for the youth teams.
Can we all agree he's been our best player so far?
You can see why, his range of pass is great and he is really nimble on the ball. Reminds me a bit of Cazorla actually, who is very two footed.
Yes, but that's not saying a lot. The standard has been gash.
Only player that has turned up, we should give him more chances.
Fellani for me.
Blind edged him out. Marked really well apart from the one Kike chip attempt and damn near set up a goal with that long ball to Fellaini.
Lingard has been on a similar level and Smalling has been as solid as ever.
All I want is to see him together with Herrera on the pitch sometime. It's not much, is it?
Lingard has been OK, not the most difficult game for our r defenders, Smalling hasn't done anything extraordinary. Poor game overall tbh.
Definitely among our better players. Tracked back and did well on the left too.
Only one to score a penalty as well.
Only one to score a penalty as well.
Hopefully we'll see a lot more of him this season. Brilliant talent.
- Status