Yagami
Good post resistant
- Joined
- Jan 27, 2013
- Messages
- 13,532
Damn, hope he's okay. Some of the insults thrown in here at Shaw are sad.
Yup, he's hardly been a colossl mess, it's just things haven't worked out for him at us really which is a shame. The injury obviously played a massive part. People pretending he was never good obviously never watched him before his move or are just completely ignoring facts.Even while here he's had spells where he was playing very well and people were talking up how good he'd be. It's not as if he's been that poor when playing for us or anything, even if there's (naturally at a young age) a lot he could improve in his game.
And to be fair he's still relatively young. Regular injuries will make it difficult for him to achieve the top level that was expected of him, but it's still feasible he could become an excellent talent.Yup, he's hardly been a colossl mess, it's just things haven't worked out for him at us really which is a shame. The injury obviously played a massive part. People pretending he was never good obviously never watched him before his move or are just completely ignoring facts.
Still only like what, 21? I mean it's his first season back after a horrific injury and there's obviously issues between himself and Mourinho. Whether or not it's with us, he could easily go on to have a cracking career.And to be fair he's still relatively young. Regular injuries will make it difficult for him to achieve the top level that was expected of him, but it's still feasible he could become an excellent talent.
Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
Best case scenario is a strain, but if they use ligament damage in terms of terminology then it's definitely worse.A ligament injury is quite a broad term isnt it? It may not be as bad as is being made out, or am i way off the mark?
(I'm no health professional after all!)
Young / Darmian as surely we would buy a new first choice LB.If we sold him, who would be our second choice LB?
For about 5 games in a United shirt, has he shown to be a natural defender. I would say he's better going forward than defending - but again, not that good since he joined.Vey unfortunate. Always liked him since his Southamton days, natural defender and very talented. I hope we give him more season to prove himself, think it will be a really bad decision to sell him now.
I've always seen him as a natural defender. His strengths, in my opinion, are defending and, when in possession, distributing the ball and just generally helping keep possession. He can play some nice Carrick/Blind-esque passes between the lines. Where he lacks is in attack when he has to beat a player or deliver that final ball.For about 5 games in a United shirt, has he shown to be a natural defender. I would say he's better going forward than defending - but again, not that good since he joined.
I don't really care what a player does outside of United or before they got here. You've admitted he has done effectively bugger all for us, which is what I was getting at anyway.PL team of the year at Southampton at 18 years of age, broke into the England set up at 18, became a first team regular at Southampton at 17, big money move to United after being courted by both Chelsea and United, looked very good for us until the leg break last season.
Overall, yeah it hasn't gone well for him since signing but he was incredible as a 17/18 year old at Southampton and looked absolute destined for the top. Let's not use revisionism just because how things have turned out for him at United.
I wasn't stunned by them. I remember a couple of decent/good performances at the beginning of the season. Then again Cleverley had a couple of those a few years ago too. Didn't amount to much in the long-run did it?There were a bunch of stunning performances at the start of last season, he was our stand out player until the broken leg at the end of September.
It's not really what you asked. The fact is that he looked a remarkable young talent and there's absolutely no disputing that. Oh I fully admit that I'm extremely disappointed with how things have worked out for him since joining us. However, he started last season extremely well before that awful injury. Naturally enough this season was always going to be difficult, all things considered. However, I'm again disappointed by what appears to be a fractured relationship between himself and Mourinho. It looks likely that he may leave this summer which is a shame.I don't really care what a player does outside of United or before they got here. You've admitted he has done effectively bugger all for us, which is what I was getting at anyway..
So you mustn't have an opinion on who we should sign this summer as everything potential targets are doing for their current clubs is irrelevant. You don't care about it.I don't really care what a player does outside of United or before they got here.
Once they join, I don't really care. Shaw has been here for 3 years and people are talking about his performances at Southampton.So you mustn't have an opinion on who we should sign this summer as everything potential targets are doing for their current clubs is irrelevant. You don't care about it.
Well you asked what's he done in his career so what did you expect? Most posters wouldn't randomly dismiss everything that happened pre 2014.Once they join, I don't really care. Shaw has been here for 3 years and people are talking about his performances at Southampton.
I expected some kind of argument justifying the extreme hype based on his United performances.Well you asked what's he done in his career so what did you expect? Most posters wouldn't randomly dismiss everything that happened pre 2014.
Of course they won't. I feel for him. He's had horrendous luck with injuries and has copped nothing but abuse with a lot of comments getting really personal.Hope all the armchair warriors on here & social media are proud. Virtually calling him a coward & a cheat for making out he is injured & not wanting to play. Absolutely disgraceful. Doubt if many will apologise, including the bully of a manager.