Found this gem in the Gotze thread:
Quote from: alonsoisared on May 20, 2016, 11:16:26 AM
Since about 2007 at various times in popular opinion we've had the best keeper, the best centre halves, the best right backs, the best midfield and the best strikers in the league/in the world. Even in the last season or two we've had that
Sakho is the best defender in the league, Coutinho the best attacking midfielder in the league, Emre Can is one of the biggest midfield talents in europe, Clyne is the best right back in the league, pretty much any player who's had a good run of form has been hailed as a future captain etc etc. While some of those might well be true we've ultimately got absolutely nothing to show for it other than a league cup win under Kenny and a series of abject finishes in the league and let downs in the latter stages of cup competitions.
For that reason I just cannot accept the idea that because we've already got bodies in a similar position to Gotze that we shouldn't prioritise signing him. When a player of his quality and experience comes along, at such a young age with his peak ahead of him, you do what it takes to sign him and worry about the rest later. I like Lallana, I like Firmino and I like Coutinho but if there is a better player available who also happens to be a winner then they need to prepare to fight for a place and prove their worth otherwise they get moved on. That's how it should be, there shouldn't be safe places in a squad, especially not for players who haven't won anything despite the opportunities they've had.
Despite that I'd say there's room on the same pitch for 3 of those 4 so I wouldn't say we'd be overstocked anyway. Having a player of Gotze's quality around might even push their performances up a level. Again I will stress that I really like Coutinho and Firmino in particular but if we really do have an opportunity to sign a world class talent for a cut price fee before he's even hit his peak then we just have to go for it. I won't be shedding a tear at the sight of one of them sitting on the bench now and then if we're beating teams and competing at the top end of the table. We need to be ruthless, these opportunities don't come around often.