[TheReligion]

He played well in the world cup though right?

 

[Globule]

I can't see Mourinho persevering with him for long, waiting for him to do something, so he's going to have to show something early on. I could easily see him being kept this summer only for Mourinho to lose patience with him and flog him in January.

 

[Jazz]

Should never have been given the No.7 shirt. It should have been explained to him that you have to earn the right to wear it. A small thing, but.....
would have kept him from being preoccupied with this 'M7' thing or whatever it is.
Honestly, should let Warren Joyce have some time with him. He's quite a sensitive kid and very wound up, so I reckon he needs careful handling. Unfortunately for him, United = pressure, and I'm not sure this is the right environment for him at this time. Don't want him sold yet though.

 

[Nighteyes]

Should never have been given the No.7 shirt. It should have been explained to him that you have to earn the right to wear it. A small thing, but.....
would have kept him from being preoccupied with this 'M7' thing or whatever it is.
Honestly, should let Warren Joyce have some time with him. He's quite a sensitive kid and very wound up, so I reckon he needs careful handling. Unfortunately for him, United = pressure, and I'm not sure this is the right environment for him at this time. Don't want him sold yet though.

Quite astonishing how you've managed to deduce all that..

 

[ChaddyP]

He played well in the world cup though right?

yes but he wasnt shackled by LVG's kill joy philosophy ... oh wait

 

[VP89]

Going by how Mourinho didn't really Salah much time and ruthlessly ditched an in-form Shurrle, Memphis doesn't have a chance.

 

[Nighteyes]

He was decent at the world cup. Nothing more.

 

[K2K]

Maybe a loan back to PSV would do his confidence wonder. He seems to keep a good relationship with the club and the supporters there.

No

If we are to loan him, it has to be to an English team. He has proven he can cut it in the Dutch league. It's this league he needs to do welI in.

Maybe Everton as Koeman seems to rate him .

 

[Rossa]

Not playing very well, is he? Not sure what his greatest assets are...

 

[CamuNoir]

Another shite game.
People saying he will improve needs to get their head checked.
I say this once again, he's in the same bracket with bebe and obertan.

 

[acnumber9]

He's actually been able to stand out as particularly poor in the middle of a performance from Utd players that makes you wonder if they picked out people from the crowd to play for them.

 

[AndyJ1985]

Just awful. He can't even do the basics properly.

 

[kenny19]

Thick cnut and I hope Jose let's him know just how average of a player he is.

 

[Adisa]

He simply isn't a very good player. It will take a while before people accept it but they will eventually get there.
I have been watching him since his PSV days.

 

[ottosec]

He's been terrible and he's getting worse every game. At this rate he won't be here in September.

 

[DWelbz19]

Thick cnut and I hope Jose let's him know just how average of a player he is.

Calm down, mate. Resorting to insulting every player to display your dissatisfaction isn't a particularly positive trait.

 

[Robbie Boy]

I genuinely can't believe how poor a signing he has turned out to be. Obviously we had to be realistic as he was coming from a very weak league, but he's somehow contrived to be absolutely abysmal and worse than anyone could have foresaw.

 

[Rajma]

I think his body balance is just all wrong, he seems to have no coordination at all when carrying the ball, through his slow pace into the mix and the outcome is that Memphis is just not a very good footballer and I struggle to see his potential to improve drastically. PSV I guess was probably a perfect match for him in terms of his qualities, slightly lower paced league and the role on the pitch and our scouts and LVG are for the blame here, by not being able to distinguish and spot that his attributes were not transferable.

 

[El-Manos]

He has been pretty shite but Blind and Jones have been worse in my opinion.

 

[Art Vandelay]

He never looks like he can move too well. Like he lacks the pace and agility to even let him do the basics.

 

[caisenma]

Depay wasnt good, but the amount of flak he gets compared to Lingard is surprising.

 

[dichinero]

Needs to be quicker in his thinking, you see what he wants to do but he takes ages to process it!

 

[GledTheRed]

Not playing very well, is he? Not sure what his greatest assets are...

Guns and his pecks.

 

[Kearnkoff69]

It's clear that he's got good enough movement to play up top, but not the mentality. I mean, it's pre-season, you're going to get subbed anyway, you had a horrid first season and have the chance to impress a new boss. And he's still playing with such a lack of energy and sharpness. It's not talent that's lacking IMO, but application. If Jose can't fix that, then he's a lost cause and will end up at a mid-table European club for the rest of his career.

 

[Raw]

He'll get more chances in pre-season and maybe 1 or 2 starts in the PL to prove his worth to United. If he's still this slow and sloppy then he's probably off. Maybe on loan?

 

[Sammyjunn]

Hasnt been half as bad as Lingard and Jones.

 

[acnumber9]

Depay wasnt good, but the amount of flak he gets compared to Lingard is surprising.

Lingard is better than him and he isn't good enough either. Players who work harder will always get a little less criticism too.

 

[11101]

He's looking well up for it which is good to see. His touch just isn't there, but on this surface it's hard to judge.

 

[m1y2]

he's so slow it's unbelievable.. Valencia is also pretty bulked up and didn't really lost speed despite being 32 soon..

 

[Von Mistelroum]

Looks worse than Bebe. It's bizarre because he has potential. I don't know whether it's lack of confidence (like Rooney who looks like someone who won a competition to play in a match when he's not confident), or whether it's that he just doesn't care, but he really looks like Bebe's less talented brother now.

 

[NoLogo]

Still hasn't convinced me that he isn't the new and more expensive Obertan. Rarely have I seen a player that was branded as an amazing talent look so shit so frequently. He really needs to show something else pretty soon or he'll spent the most part of season watching us play from the stands.

 

[flappyjay]

Dortmund get Dembele for 15 million and we are stuck with this clown.

 

[Adam-Utd]

People saying he's slow, he was against Sokratis who is IMO 1 of the fastest defenders out there. Even Rashford couldn't go passed him 1v1. Think the heat would of sapped him more than anybody though with the extra muscle he carries.

 

[Classical Mechanic]

he's so slow it's unbelievable.. Valencia is also pretty bulked up and didn't really lost speed despite being 32 soon..

Val is naturally a really powerful guy. I get the impression that Memphis lifts, which would explain why he is deceptively slow and weak.

 

[Sb_16]

He sure does love his thighs. He's the Ronaldo of lower extremities.

 

[shamans]

It's clear that he's got good enough movement to play up top, but not the mentality. I mean, it's pre-season, you're going to get subbed anyway, you had a horrid first season and have the chance to impress a new boss. And he's still playing with such a lack of energy and sharpness. It's not talent that's lacking IMO, but application. If Jose can't fix that, then he's a lost cause and will end up at a mid-table European club for the rest of his career.

I hope I'm proved wrong but from what I am seeing right now, it is talent that's lacking. I just don't see it

 

[sammyvine]

He's slow. He's been like that since PSV
He can't beat a man for pace and that's a problem especially as a wide player. He isn't a good dribbler either

 

[Natener]

I hope I'm proved wrong but from what I am seeing right now, it is talent that's lacking. I just don't see it

10x the talent of Nani apparently, or so I heard.

 

[Adisa]

People keep saying he's talented. Is he feck.
There is literally no aspect of the game he is excellent at.

 

[Morpheus 7]

I want him to succeed but he simply doesn't work hard enough for the team. He should have been well up for this pre season but hasn't been at it, at all. The amount of occasions today he just walked around was shocking. He wasn't pressing or forcing the dortmund line to do anything. Some comments on here have been clueless too. He is talented and only an idiot would think otherwise. It's his work ethic, overall team work and attitude which is the issue. His confidence was clearly knocked under Van Gaal but you can't defend a player who's not trying.