[drdoityourself]

He gets the ball, waits for the overlap. If the overlap isn't on he'll pass it back again. The opponents know him now and never commit more than one defender to him, so that really stifles our attack. We really don't have anyone else, Martial doesn't work there, Januzaj is out of favour. So it is of paramount importance that we sign a qualified right winger this summer. It could do wonders for our attack to have threat on both flanks.

 

[mav_9me]

He is not good enough to be our starting right winger every game. He should be a back up squad member. Definitely good enough for that role.

That's why I was surprised when we ended up not going for mane or anybody else for that right wing.

 

[m1y2]

Got better in the second half. Martial was also shit in the first half and played in his preferred position..

Dont understand why we dont give a chance to pereira who is certainly better suited to the wing with his skillset even though its not his best position but so isnt Lingard's

 

[Ryan7]

Its been clear for weeks on end he's miles from good enough. He offers nothing whatsoever. He's not even an average player. Needs to be sold in the summer.

 

[caisenma]

He doesnt even get subbed off anymore... He's a 90 minute man every match he's eligible, but he does so very little. I just dont get it.

 

[JoaquinJoaquin]

Rather put Valencia back on the wings alongside Valera.

Lingard is one of the reasons the club is struggling. Putting up mediocre players from the academy because it is the United way.

Totally agree. In fact with the inclusion of Williams on the bench yesterday i'm now sure that LVG is trying to give out as many first team debuts as possible to deflect attention from his poor performances as a manager (and that is no reflection on Williams btw, I think he has a big future).

I've said from the start that Lingard is average, yet I got labelled 'a hater'. It's all well and good wanting an academy player coming through and playing in the first team, But he has got to be good enough to continue playing in that position, which Lingard simply isn't. He is this years Tom Cleverly or Kieran Richardson before that. You can accommodate those type of players if we have a great team around them but at this present time we simply do not, and cannot afford to carry passengers which Lingard is, Like it or not.

 

[Nighteyes]

Lingard is starting on merit and this despite playing in an unfamiliar role.

Ideally, we'd have someone better but that's not Lingard's fault.

 

[drdoityourself]

Lingard is starting on merit and this despite playing in an unfamiliar role.

Ideally, we'd have someone better but that's not Lingard's fault.

Can you still call it an unfamiliar role? He's only played this one position in the senior team.

 

[RedSky]

He gets fouled a lot. Thats something.

 

[Nighteyes]

Can you still call it an unfamiliar role? He's only played this one position in the senior team.

You can. Not only is he playing in an unfamiliar position but he's been asked to play the role of a traditional winger which requires him to beat his man which he's not very good at. He's still done a decent job of it.

 

[Minkaro]

He'd odd. I like him, and think he could (and does) score his fair share of goals, but he'd also be probably the first name in our present starting XI that I'd want replacing in the summer. Definitely keep him as a squad member though.

 

[Bubz27]

Anonymous tonight.

 

[Lawman]

He's substandard

 

[Walters_19_MuFc]

I thought he had a decent game, especially in the second half. Give us drive through the middle that we often lack.

 

[royboy16]

Needs to cut out the diving,other than that thought he was ok tonight.

 

[Truedevil]

One of our better players, nowhere near good enough though.

 

[facund]

Involved in nearly all our good interplay tonight and carried the ball through the centre reasonably well. Not sure what his actual position was because he seemed to be popping up everywhere and seemed a lot more comfortable than being stuck out on the right.

 

[drdoityourself]

Needs to cut out the diving,other than that thought he was ok tonight.

He can't really shake players off or go past them, so he opts to win a free kick every time. That's pretty intelligent because he knows he can't beat players.
He'll run with the ball in space, but when there's confrontation he just shifts responsability to the next guy. To have someone like that in our front 3, is far from good enough.
He had a fine game by his standards, but for me his standard is well below what I believe makes a Manchester United player.

 

[Hed Zitin]

He was alright, but that is his level.

 

[Devil may care]

He tried hard just lacks a bit of final quality.

 

[khoazany]

All of our freekick takers are average so not much point of him winning freekicks these days.

 

[MadDogg]

Played well in general, and his superior pace and ability to run at and past people got us on the front foot quite a few times. But just like Fellaini, the final ball never quite worked.

 

[KiD MoYeS]

He's a Swansea standard player, lets be honest.

 

[drdoityourself]

Played well in general, and his superior pace and ability to run at and past people got us on the front foot quite a few times. But just like Fellaini, the final ball never quite worked.

He can't run past people. His pace is also average.

 

[Zoo]

He did well.

 

[caisenma]

Average. Did a couple of nice things but once again average at best.

 

[dwd]

He's only in the team because of where he was born. He's not good enough, sadly. Not his fault. Won't be in the XI next season (I hope).

 

[stepic]

Squad player at best

 

[GE]

I still don't really rate him.

He's a hard worker, but that's about it...

 

[dogwithabone]

He wouldn't get anywhere near the Spurs side, the Arsenal side, City, Leicester, Chelsea, Liverpool......the list goes on and on....

 

[Di Maria's angel]

I commend him for his effort, he isn't a bad player, it's just that he isn't brilliant, either.

I do think he'd have thrived under Sir Alex.

 

[No11]

I thought he had a decent game, especially in the second half. Give us drive through the middle that we often lack.

I agree, he did ok along with Martial and Rashford. Problem is no midfield players going beyond them then things basically break down.
The midfield is utter shite.

 

[No11]

I commend him for his effort, he isn't a bad player, it's just that he isn't brilliant, either.

I do think he'd have thrived under Sir Alex.

Take out DDG and Martial and your statement could apply to any of the others.

 

[J-Stander]

He wouldn't get anywhere near the Spurs side, the Arsenal side, City, Leicester, Chelsea, Liverpool......the list goes on and on....

He wouldn't get in most teams in the league. Championship player.

 

[Harold_Giles]

Any idea if he could play full back? He'd be quite good going forward, but perhaps he'd be a huge weak link in defense?

 

[Kevin]

Players like him starting is fine when it's one or two of these. Two or three of these jokers in defence, two in midfield (carrick is done), one in attack is frightening. Mata just barely makes the grade for someone who is supposed to be the technical maestro of a top team.

 

[J-Stander]

Any idea if he could play full back? He'd be quite good going forward, but perhaps he'd be a huge weak link in defense?

Any idea if he'd be good in net? Quick off his line, but shit at saving stuff. Jesus Christ.

 

[Ferguson]

I thought he was good. Mata was the one with his lack of pace on the right wing trying to cover Varela's man and failing to do so time and again in this match.

 

[MadDogg]

He can't run past people. His pace is also average.

I'm not talking about beating people in 1v1's, where he does tend to struggle. But there were a number of times the Liverpool midfield were trying to hold their positions and he'd go between them to put us on the front foot in fairly good position. And pace-wise, while he'll struggle against many fullbacks, he's faster than many (most?) midfielders. And certainly faster than Mata.

 

[Harold_Giles]

Any idea if he'd be good in net? Quick off his line, but shit at saving stuff. Jesus Christ.

Get off your high horse, mate. He's already been tried at wing back, so it's not like this a ridiculous speculation.