May be we should do a voting for next draft ? After the monopoly draft I would like a more straightforward draft with no cards/surprise rounds etc, hopefully not much luck involved at all. So either the 4-way or physio's no-mate draft sound good to me.
Next Draft - Ideas and Discussions
- Thread starter Edgar Allan Pillow
- Start date
Things have finally started to settled down a bit so please count me in for whatever the next draft is.
4 way already has 13 sign-ups
Any thoughts on my auction idea?
Any thoughts on my auction idea?
Good to know, hope everything's all right now.
I'm in for whatever draft is next, vote for auction though.
@Edgar Allan Pillow I'm happy to play the 4 way draft
I'm for the 4 way draft next as well.
Love your auction idea as well @Edgar Allan Pillow too for that matter, but slightly more prefer the 4 way one.
Love your auction idea as well @Edgar Allan Pillow too for that matter, but slightly more prefer the 4 way one.
So what's the next draft then?
1. Edgar's 4-Way Draft
2. Chester's Unproven Draft
3. Edgar's Auction Draft
4. Physiocrat's No Mates 46-66 Draft -Physio,
5. Tuppet's chain Draft
Choose one.
2. Chester's Unproven Draft
3. Edgar's Auction Draft
4. Physiocrat's No Mates 46-66 Draft -Physio,
5. Tuppet's chain Draft
Choose one.
Edgar, you need choose one of yours.
I'd love to play the next one. Could someone explain or quote how each of these drafts work.
Edgar's 4 Way - https://www.redcafe.net/threads/next-draft-idea-discussion.403961/page-89#post-21092406
Chester's Nonproven - https://www.redcafe.net/threads/next-draft-idea-discussion.403961/page-90#post-21133485
Edgar's Auction: https://www.redcafe.net/threads/next-draft-idea-discussion.403961/page-91#post-21242304
Physio's No Mate - With the decades mentioned (46-66) you should pick a team, but none of your players can have played with each other in club/NT.
Tuppet's Chain - Flip side of No mates Draft. You can only pick a player who has played with your previous pick.
Chester's Nonproven - https://www.redcafe.net/threads/next-draft-idea-discussion.403961/page-90#post-21133485
Edgar's Auction: https://www.redcafe.net/threads/next-draft-idea-discussion.403961/page-91#post-21242304
Physio's No Mate - With the decades mentioned (46-66) you should pick a team, but none of your players can have played with each other in club/NT.
Tuppet's Chain - Flip side of No mates Draft. You can only pick a player who has played with your previous pick.
Why? Prefer to run no mates later?
I may be interested to play next draft
Not really. It's just I thought you'd want to play one of your own design.
@Joga Bonito what do you do for a living?
1. Edgar's 4-Way Draft MOBY
2. Chester's Unproven Draft MOBY
3. Edgar's Auction Draft MOBY
4. Physiocrat's No Mates 46-66 Draft -Physio, MOBY
5. Tuppet's chain Draft MOBY
Choose one. MOBY
2. Chester's Unproven Draft MOBY
3. Edgar's Auction Draft MOBY
4. Physiocrat's No Mates 46-66 Draft -Physio, MOBY
5. Tuppet's chain Draft MOBY
Choose one. MOBY
Why so random?
If you don't mind me asking.Why so random?
So 4-way then?
Maybe, he believe you work in the football businessWhy so random?
I probably like Edgars 4 way best as it's something fresh and in for that one.
Professional Caf poster - I'd pay good money to read those Classic Player threads.
sign me up for anything please
So opinions? Do you think the pools are balanced enough? Maybe open managers to 2x managers per player?
Probably 2x managers per player.
Decade is by far the best pool - it gives you most options.
Decade is by far the best pool - it gives you most options.
Think managers is way too weak. Even with 2x. Maybe have a rest of the world pool (Apart from the countries already chosen I mean)
You may have overlaps. For example 2 people may choose the same decade, which make it more dicier.
I don't mind hiking it up to 3 managers too, though feel that'd be a bit too much.
Maybe Pick Top 2 manager pools and open it up as common which you get in addition to your own chosen 2 managers.
maybe swap manager pool with the league pool....
It will be seriously overlapping with the club's one.
Yeah indeed, but the biggest pool definitely is the decade as it stands - it will overlap 3 generation of players, even with multiple managers choosing the same decade.
The way I see it you have decades pool - you choose the 80's and that's players who are ending their careers in the early 80's, at the peak of their powers in the mid 80's and all the young ones emerging in the later part of the decade.
Whilst if someone chooses a manager if we take 2 of them (possible overlaps as well) your looking at around 200 players pool at best (including fringe players) for a good 10-15 years career at top level per manager.
thats the point isnt it? You pick someone that screws as many others as possible.....maybe keep it as it is and help the manager group in other ways(give them first pick or picks or let them choose a position in the draft order or something like that).
Dont like the two manager idea, somehow it ruins the spirit of the draft IMO
They will have the hardest job but probably the most enjoyful ride....
.
The point is - the league managers would have access to many club's pools, which will give them an unfair advantage over the club managers.
Imagine - you only have United pool and your opponent can pick literally anyone who you can, plus any player from Aesenal/Liverpool etc squad
With the decades criteria will only the peak from that decade count?
E.g. If I pick 90s Maradona he won't be as good as the 80s version.
To avoid this maybe decades of birth may be better?
E.g. If I pick 90s Maradona he won't be as good as the 80s version.
To avoid this maybe decades of birth may be better?
Yeah indeed. Not to mention that league pool would immediately be the biggest one and also overlaps to a big extend with the country one.
point taken, crap suggestion.
It's usually birth decades.
As it is it - it is players who have played not born in.